⬇️ Prefer to listen instead? ⬇️
- 🍄 Mushroom growing kits have a high success rate, often over 90%. This is because their substrates come pre-sterilized and already have mushroom growth started.
- 🦠 DIY mushroom cultivation has a high failure rate for beginners, largely due to contamination.
- ⏳ Kits need only 5–10 minutes of daily care. DIY grows take hours each week.
- ♻️ Growing kits grow mushrooms many times and create less waste, especially compared to failed DIY tries.
- 📚 Studies show that growing mushrooms helps with food sustainability and growing food at home.
Mushroom Growing Kits vs DIY: Which Is Better?
Interest in home mushroom cultivation is growing fast. People care more about sustainability, home-grown food, and how fungi work. If you want to start, you will usually choose one of two ways: mushroom growing kits or the DIY method. Both ways let you grow fresh, edible mushrooms at home. But they need different amounts of work, skill, and give different results. This guide looks at the good and bad points of each. It will help you pick the best way to grow mushrooms.
What Is a DIY Mushroom Growing Setup?
DIY mushroom growing means you do everything in the growing process. You put together all parts yourself. This includes getting spores or mycelium. It also means you prepare and clean the growing materials.
Required Materials and Tools for DIY Mushroom Cultivation
DIY setups need patience and some special tools. Here is what you often need:
- Grain Spawn or Agar Cultures: These are like the seeds for your mushrooms. You can buy them from a good seller. Or you can grow them from clone material.
- Growing Substrate: These are natural materials like hardwood sawdust, straw, coffee grounds, or a mix of grains. These give food to your mushrooms.
- Sterilization Equipment: This part is very important. Most DIY growers use a pressure cooker (like the Presto 23-Quart) to clean the growing materials and kill anything that might compete with the mushrooms.
- Containers: Filter patch bags, mason jars, or monotubs hold your growing mushrooms.
- Clean Controlled Environment: Cleanliness is key. Many experienced growers build glove boxes. Or they buy laminar flow hoods to stop contamination.
- Monitoring Devices: Thermometers, hygrometers, and timers help keep the growing conditions just right.
DIY mushroom growing can feel very good. It lets you change everything as you like. But it has problems. The main ones are contamination risk, and that setting it up and watching it takes a lot of time.
What Is a Mushroom Growing Kit?
Mushroom growing kits make growing easier. They give you a product that is ready to grow. These kits have growing material already started with mushroom mycelium. You just need to give the kit fresh air, water, and some light.
Common Types of Mushroom Growing Kits
There are many types of kits you can buy. Each one has its own uses:
- Block Kits: This is the most common kind. These have a growing block with mushroom growth inside a filter bag. This bag helps air move in and out cleanly.
- Jar Kits: Many people like these for desks or small areas. They have jars full of mushroom growth, ready to make mushrooms.
- Log Kits: These are good for growing outdoors. They use hardwood logs with mushroom plugs planted in them. You can grow shiitake or oyster mushrooms this way for months or years.
Kits are made to be simple. They are great for new growers, students, or anyone without the time or desire to learn the hard science of fungi.
Easy and Simple: Growing Kits for Any Home
One big reason people like mushroom growing kits is how easy they are to use. Once your kit arrives:
- You remove it from its box.
- Mist it with filtered water 1–3 times daily.
- Wait for mushrooms to grow within 7 to 14 days.
Grow kits eliminate the need for:
- Making growing material mixes or keeping cultures clean.
- Using specialized sterilization equipment.
- Finding a special spot in your home to grow.
Kits are small. You can put them on a windowsill, kitchen counter, or even a bathroom shelf. They are easy to use. They make growing mushrooms simple and a pleasant daily task.
Success Rates: Why Kits Offer Sure Harvests
Mushroom kits are made by professionals in clean rooms. They use commercial methods. This makes them much better than DIY setups made at home. The growing material you get in a kit is:
- Already fully colonized by mycelium.
- Sealed in a sterile bag or container.
- Closely monitored before shipping.
This means that when it arrives at your door, you have already done most of the growing work. If you mist it right and give it air, you will probably see mushrooms grow in a few days. Most store-bought kits have a success rate over 90%. This is true for easy kinds like oyster or lion's mane.
But DIY mushroom growing has many places where things can go wrong: contamination when you start growth, wrong water levels in the growing material, or slow mushroom growth. If you make a mistake at any of these steps, your harvest could be late by weeks. Or it might not happen at all.
Contamination: The Hidden Risk of DIY
There are many types of fungi. Not all of them are good for your mushrooms. When you start DIY mushroom growing, one of the hardest things is to stop contamination. Other molds and bacteria can grow quickly. They often do this before your mushroom growth can spread.
Mycology expert Paul Stamets writes that “many grow failures are contamination-related, especially among beginners who miss small but important cleaning rules” (Stamets, 2000).
DIY growing risks include:
- Introducing unclean air while inoculating.
- Using improperly sterilized substrate materials.
- Handling cultures without gloves or masks.
Growing materials with contamination often look green or black. They can also smell bad. You cannot save them. But grow kits are made for weeks in clean labs. They arrive with mushroom growth already started. This keeps them safe from germs in the air. This means new growers usually won't have early contamination problems with kits.
Time Commitment: Passive vs Active Growing
Growing mushrooms from scratch can take many hours each week:
- Preparing agar plates or spore syringes.
- Sterilizing substrates in a pressure cooker.
- Watching mushroom growth. Also, changing humidity, light, or air flow every day.
- Dealing with issues like trichoderma mold or too-wet growing materials.
This way takes more work. But it is good if you like doing it. But if you are busy, or just want a good harvest, mushroom kits need only a few minutes of care daily. You just mist them daily and look at them. This is usually enough until harvest time.
Kits are a calm, easy hobby—like watering a plant. DIY, on the other hand, is more like running a science experiment.
Beginner-Friendly & Educational Value
Mushroom growing kits let anyone curious grow tasty or medicinal mushrooms at home. You don't need any experience. They are a good way to learn about:
- Biology and life sciences: Teachers often use them in schools to show how fungi grow.
- Learning about sustainability: They show how to grow food from waste or materials that break down naturally.
- Health and wellness: Many kits grow kinds of mushrooms known for helping the brain, reducing swelling, or boosting the immune system.
After you finish growing one kit, you will know healthy mushroom growth. You will also know what contamination looks like. And you will know what conditions mushrooms like. This is important if you want to try DIY growing next.
Cost Comparison: Hidden Costs of DIY
At first, DIY looks cheaper. But if you add up the cost of materials, tools, and time, grow kits might actually cost less. This is true for new growers.
| Cost Factor | Mushroom Growing Kit ($30–$40) | DIY Cultivation ($100–$250+) |
|---|---|---|
| Pre-colonized Substrate | ✅ Included | ❌ Need to buy spawn: $20–$30 |
| Sterilization Equipment | ✅ Not required | ❌ Pressure cooker: $80–$150 |
| Containers & Grow Bags | ✅ Included | ❌ Jars, tubs, or bags: $10–$30 |
| Hygienic Equipment | ✅ Included via sealed packaging | ❌ Filters, gloves, masks, bleach: $10–$20 |
| Rate of Success | ✅ High (~90%) | ❌ Changes a lot; new growers often fail |
| Time Investment | ✅ Minimal, 5–10 min/day | ❌ Several hours/week |
Grow kits give sure results. There is little risk of making expensive mistakes or wasting materials. DIY only saves money for skilled growers. These are people who can keep getting good harvests.
Advanced Growers: When DIY Can Be Good
Kits are best for most people. But sometimes DIY mushroom growing is a better choice:
- Growing More: If you want to grow many pounds each month, DIY ways to grow a lot (like monotubs, grow shelves) become cheaper.
- Growing Rare Kinds: Some rare mushrooms—like Reishi, Morel, or Cordyceps—are not usually sold as kits. This is because they need very specific growing conditions.
- Cloning and Mixing Kinds: DIY gives more control to mushroom scientists. They can try different genetics or growing material mixes.
- Self-Sufficient Growing: For homesteaders, using waste materials—like spent coffee grounds or wood chips—can help them grow mushrooms on their own for a long time.
DIY growing gives you more ways to change things. But it needs patience, strictness, and skill to fix problems.
Sustainability and Waste Reduction
For sustainability, mushroom growing kits are better than DIY setups in a few ways:
- Fewer Failed Grows: New growers often get contamination in DIY setups. This means they throw out growing material.
- Compostability: Many kits come in compostable or recyclable packaging.
- Smart Use of Materials: Kits often use used materials like sawdust and straw as growing beds.
After a kit stops making mushrooms, the leftover growing material full of mushroom growth, called “spent blocks,” can be used:
- Crumbled into compost piles.
- Used as garden mulch.
- Rehydrated to fruit again (in some cases).
Failed DIY grows, on the other hand, often create more waste. This is because each part is put together by hand. And contaminated parts must be thrown away.
Types of Mushrooms That Grow Well in Kits
Not all mushrooms grow well in beginner setups. But many tasty or medicinal kinds are just right for kits.
Top Mushroom Varieties for Kits
- Oyster (Pleurotus spp.): Very strong and fast-growing; grows well in most places.
- Lion’s Mane (Hericium erinaceus): Known to help brain health and is easy to grow.
- Shiitake (Lentinula edodes): Has a rich, savory taste; takes a bit longer to make mushrooms, but grows a lot.
- Chestnut Mushrooms: Has a special nutty taste; you can find these in some advanced kits.
- Enoki (Flammulina velutipes): Grows best in cooler conditions and more specialty kits.
Look for a grow kit that includes mushrooms that are easy for new growers. This will help you get good first harvests.
Tips to Get the Most From Your Mushroom Growing Kit
Even with a kit, doing things the right way helps you get the biggest, healthiest harvests.
Key Care Tips
- Humidity: Keep humidity at 80–90% by misting often or using a humidity tent made from a clear plastic bag.
- Temperature: Keep the temperature right for your mushroom type. Usually 60–75°F is best.
- Light: Use indirect sunlight or low-strength LED lights for 12 hours daily.
- Cleanliness: Always wash hands before handling; avoid touching the mycelium directly.
- Harvest Time: Pick mushrooms when their caps are fully grown. Do this before they release spores to make sure they taste and feel their best.
Rehydrating or soaking the block after the first flush can help a second or third group of mushrooms grow.
Frequently Asked Questions
How long does it take to grow mushrooms with a kit?
Kits usually start making mushrooms within 7–14 days after you start them. This depends on the mushroom type and conditions.
Can mushroom kits be reused?
Most kits will grow mushrooms 2–3 times. After that, they don't have as many nutrients. But some growers put them in compost. Or they try to get them to grow again by adding water.
Are mushroom kits legal to own or grow?
Yes—for mushrooms you eat or use for health. But psychedelic mushroom kits are against the law in most places.
Can I learn DIY skills from using a kit?
Absolutely. Kits give you direct experience. You learn about the right environment, how mushroom pins form, and how to pick mushrooms.
Why Mushroom Growing Kits Are a Good Start
Mushroom growing kits are the easiest, safest, and best way to start growing mushrooms at home. They make it simple. They make it easier to learn. And they grow tasty, medicinal mushrooms in days. You don't need lab tools or lots of technical knowledge. DIY growing can be good for long-term projects and trying new things. But kits give fast results. They help new growers get successful harvests before they get more serious about mycology.
Ready to start growing at home?
[Look at our chosen mushroom growing kits →]
[Get our FREE Starter Guide to Growing Mushrooms]
[Starter Bundles: Tools + Cultures + Kits to Begin Growing]
Citations
Stamets, P. (2000). Growing Gourmet and Medicinal Mushrooms. Ten Speed Press.
Chang, S. T., & Miles, P. G. (2004). Mushrooms: Cultivation, Nutritional Value, Medicinal Effect, and Environmental Impact (2nd ed.). CRC Press.
U.S. Department of Agriculture. (2020). USDA National Agricultural Statistics Service.
ResearchAndMarkets. (2022). Global Edible Mushroom Market Report.
